Rabbi Yoichonon does NOT assume that they ONLY argue with Shivas Haminim but with Borey Nefoshois...They argue with all foods. הוא הדין בדברים שאין טעונין ברכה לאחריהן במקומן Rabbi Yehuda is mentioned because...
Rabbi Yehuda rules to repeat the first berocho to continue eating any food even Shivas haminim. Shivas haminim is mentioned to highlight how strict Rabbi Yehuda
What does R' Yehuda say from the Braiso that talks about שינוי מקום after eating Shivas Haminim?
Rabbi Yehuda rules repeat the first berocho to continue eating the Shivas haminim
לימא תיהוי תיובתא דרבי יוחנן We logically assumed that they ONLY argue with Shivas Haminim but with Borey Nefoshois...The Rabbonon hold...
Rabonon also rule to repeat the first berocho to continue eating Borey Nefoshois type of foods
וְלָאו
Have we not
נֵימָא
Let us say
לימא תיהוי תיובתא דרבי יוחנן we logically assumed that they ONLY argue with Shivas Haminim but with Borey Nefoshois... Rabbi Yehuda rules...
Rabbi Yehuda rules to repeat the first berocho to continue eating Borey Nefoshois type of foods
What does the Rabbonon (Tana Kama) say from the Braiso talks about שינוי מקום after eating Shivas Haminim
Rabonon [Tana Kama] rule NOT to repeat the first berocho to continue eating the Shivas haminim
מֵהָא נָמֵי
that from here also
תִּיהַוֵי תְּיוּבְתָּא
it should be a refutation?
Your experience on this site will be improved by allowing cookies.